Biggest Plot Holes In Harry Potter

"Help will always be given at Hogwarts to those who deserve it." - Dumbledore

· 5 min read
A boy with glasses playing with a wand

The Harry Potter book and film series by J.K. Rowling has charmed millions of readers and moviegoers worldwide.

Numerous fans have been motivated to learn more about the world of magic and wizardry by the series' extensive mythology and complex plot, which have made it a revered classic.

Even devoted fans, nevertheless, have pointed out several plot holes in the films that are challenging to explain in light of the canon.

The major plot holes in the Harry Potter films will be examined in this article, and we'll try to explain why they exist.

Time-Turner Inconsistencies

A girl and a boy sharing a pendant

Hermione Granger utilizes a Time-Turner in Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban to attend various classes simultaneously.

The plot, however, suffers as a result of some contradictions.

For example, if Harry and Hermione used the Time-Turner to rescue Buckbeak, why didn't they use it to save Harry's parents from Voldemort?

This is a significant plot hole, as the Time-Turner has the potential to disrupt the established timeline and create paradoxes.

One explanation for this inconsistency is that the Ministry of Magic may have restricted the use of Time-Turners for certain situations, such as changing major historical events.

Additionally, the use of the Time-Turner in The Prisoner of Azkaban may have been a one-time occurrence due to specific circumstances.

Apparition and Portkeys Inconsistencies

Various people holding onto one boot

In the Harry Potter books and films, apparitions and portkeys are two means of fast long-distance travel for wizards.

Their application varies throughout the films, though. In Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, for instance, the Hogwarts students must travel a long way and risk their lives to get to the Triwizard Tournament.

Why didn't they just use a portkey or an apparition?

The Ministry of Magic may have imposed limitations on the usage of various modes of transportation, which is one explanation for this.

It's also likely that the Hogwarts professors intended for the voyage to serve as a test of the pupils' knowledge and talents.

Dumbledore's Plan Inconsistencies

Two men looking down as galaxies and stars hover above them

Dumbledore is described as a great strategist who consistently appears to be one step ahead of his adversaries throughout the Harry Potter series.

It's challenging to ignore the discrepancies in his intentions, though. For instance, given that the Horcruxes were crucial to stopping Voldemort, why did Dumbledore choose not to inform Harry more about them?

Dumbledore might have been trying to keep Harry out of harm's way in an effort to protect him, which is one interpretation of this.

He might also have been trying to hide the fact that they were looking for Horcruxes from Voldemort.

Voldemort's Lack of Knowledge

A bald man with white eyes

Voldemort is depicted in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince as having enormous power and knowledge.

There are some contradictions in his ignorance of the circumstances behind the prophecy he thought applied to Harry, though.

Why, for instance, was Voldemort unaware that Neville Longbottom might have been the intended recipient of the prophecy rather than Harry?

Voldemort's passion for Harry and desire for vengeance may have caused him to become blind, which is one explanation for what happened.

In addition, he might have overestimated his skills and the importance of the prophecy due to his arrogance.

Ron's Knowledge of the Chamber of Secrets

Three children in school uniforms

In Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Even though his sister Ginny had been nearly killed after being possessed by the Tom Riddle diary, Ron Weasley is astonished to learn about the Chamber of Secrets and its history.

Why was Ron not informed about the Chamber of Secrets by Ginny or anybody else in the Weasley family?

One explanation for this might be that Ginny was too traumatized by her event to talk to her family about it.

Ron might perhaps have been too young at the time to properly comprehend the seriousness of the circumstance and the background of the Chamber of Secrets.

It's also conceivable that Ginny did not want her family to be bothered by learning about her possession and the threat it posed.

Snape's Motivations

A man with long hair staring into the distance

Severus Snape is portrayed as a complex figure with a shrouded motivation and a mystery past in the Harry Potter books.

However, there are several contradictions in his behavior that make it challenging to understand how he could ultimately remain faithful to Dumbledore and the Order of the Phoenix.

For instance, why, after becoming aware that Lily Potter was in danger, did Snape continue to work for Voldemort for such a long time?

This can be explained by the fact that Snape was deeply conflicted and was battling his own guilt and sorrow.

He might have also thought that by operating from within Voldemort's ranks and obtaining intelligence for Dumbledore and the Order, he could accomplish more good.

Wrapping Up!

Despite the writers' and filmmakers' best efforts, there are numerous difficult-to-explain plot holes in the Harry Potter films.

However, it is feasible to offer some believable explanations for these discrepancies by looking at the characters' motivations and the established canon of the series.

While they might not entirely close the story gaps, they can aid fans in appreciating the depth and intricacy of the Harry Potter universe.

5 Plot Holes in Makoto Shinkai’s Suzume Left Unexplained!
Suzume, the 2022 popular movie by Makoto Shinkai was a grand visual treat but did leave so many questions.


What are the Harry Potter movies based on?

The Harry Potter movies are based on the bestselling book series of the same name by author J.K. Rowling.

How many Harry Potter movies are there?

There are a total of 8 Harry Potter movies, each covering one of the seven books in the series, with the final book split into two films.

Who directed the Harry Potter movies?

The movies were directed by multiple directors, including Chris Columbus, Alfonso Cuarón, Mike Newell, and David Yates.

Where were the Harry Potter movies filmed?

The Harry Potter movies were primarily filmed in England, with locations including Leavesden Film Studios, Oxford University, and Alnwick Castle.

What age rating are the Harry Potter movies?

The Harry Potter movies are rated PG or PG-13, depending on the film, for some mild violence, frightening images, and thematic elements.